You know SEO matters.
Your competitors are showing up above you. Your website isn’t bringing in as many enquiries as you’d like. Maybe you’ve even had a go at SEO yourself.
So now you’re wondering:
Do I actually need an SEO company?
Maybe.
Helpful start, we know.
The reality is that not every business needs to hire an SEO agency. Some can manage perfectly well themselves. Others reach a point where doing it internally starts costing more time than it saves.
The question isn’t really whether an SEO company is “better”.
It’s whether outsourcing SEO makes sense for where your business is right now.
Here’s how we’d work that out.
Can you do SEO yourself?
Absolutely.
There’s nothing stopping you learning SEO and doing a lot of it yourself.
You can research keywords, improve page titles, write content, set up Google Search Console and make plenty of useful changes without paying an agency.
For a smaller business with a relatively straightforward website, that might be enough to get started.
The issue usually isn’t whether you can learn SEO.
It’s whether you have the time to do it properly.
SEO quickly becomes more than changing a few page titles.
There’s technical SEO, content, keyword research, competitor analysis, internal linking, performance monitoring, conversion tracking and everything else that comes with keeping a website moving.
If you’ve got the time and genuinely enjoy getting stuck into it, brilliant.
If SEO has been sitting at the bottom of your to-do list for the last six months, that probably tells you something too.
When does DIY SEO stop making sense?
Usually when one of two things happens.
Either the website becomes more complicated, or the opportunity becomes valuable enough that guessing starts feeling risky.
Maybe organic search has become one of your main sources of enquiries.
Maybe you’ve got hundreds or thousands of pages.
Maybe traffic suddenly dropped and you have no idea why.
Or maybe your competitors have started investing heavily and you’re watching them gradually move ahead.
At that point, SEO starts needing more time, better tools and more specialist knowledge.
You could still do everything yourself.
The better question is whether that’s the best use of your time.
If you run the business and spend every Friday afternoon trying to understand canonical tags, there’s probably something else you could be doing.
What about hiring someone in-house?
That can be a really good option.
Having somebody inside the business means they’re close to the team, understand what’s happening day to day and can spend all of their time focusing on your brand.
For larger businesses with enough SEO work to justify a full-time role, that can make complete sense.
But hiring internally and hiring an SEO agency aren’t quite the same thing.
One SEO specialist might be brilliant at content and strategy but less experienced technically.
Another might be incredibly technical but not particularly strong at copywriting.
SEO covers a lot of ground.
An agency gives you access to a wider mix of skills without needing to employ a technical SEO specialist, content writer, strategist and developer separately.
That doesn’t automatically make an agency better.
It just means the economics can look different.
SEO agency vs in-house: which is better?
There isn’t a winner.
It depends on the business.
In-house SEO can make sense if:
You have enough ongoing work for a dedicated person.
SEO is a major part of your growth plans.
You want somebody completely embedded in the business.
You have other specialists internally who can support them.
An SEO agency can make sense if:
You need several different SEO skills.
You don’t want to build an entire SEO team.
Your internal marketing team needs additional support.
You want access to specialist tools and experience.
You need somebody to take ownership of the strategy and delivery.
And sometimes businesses use both.
An internal marketing manager might work with an SEO agency for technical work, content strategy or additional resource.
It doesn’t have to be one or the other.
How do you know when it's time to hire an SEO agency?
There are usually a few signs.
You don't know why you're not ranking
You’ve updated pages, written blogs and maybe even changed the website.
Still nothing.
At this point, doing more without understanding the problem can just create more work.
An SEO agency should be able to look at the website properly and work out what’s getting in the way.
You're getting traffic but not enquiries
This is another common one.
Google Analytics says traffic is growing, so technically things look positive.
But the phone isn’t ringing.
That could be an SEO issue. You might be attracting the wrong searches.
It could also be a website or conversion problem.
Either way, someone needs to connect those dots rather than celebrating the traffic graph.
Your competitors keep appearing above you
If competitors are consistently outranking you for the searches that matter, there’s usually a reason.
Maybe their content is better.
Maybe their website is stronger technically.
Maybe they’ve been investing in SEO for years.
Or maybe they simply understand the search opportunity better.
The answer isn’t automatically “write more blogs”.
You need to understand what they’re doing well and where you can realistically compete.
Nobody internally has time for SEO
This might be the simplest reason of all.
Your marketing team knows what needs doing.
They just haven’t got the time to do it.
That’s a perfectly good reason to outsource.
Sometimes an agency isn’t there because the business doesn’t understand SEO. It’s there because the business needs more hands.
When probably shouldn't you hire an SEO agency?
SEO agencies aren’t right for everybody.
If you need enquiries next week, SEO probably isn’t your best first move. Paid advertising could make more sense while you build organic visibility in the background.
If nobody searches for what you sell, traditional SEO might also have limited value.
And if your budget is so tight that every pound spent needs to generate an immediate return, committing to a longer-term SEO strategy could put too much pressure on the channel too quickly.
There’s also no point hiring an agency if you’re not prepared to work with them.
A decent SEO strategy needs input.
We need to understand your customers, your priorities, your sales process and what a genuinely good enquiry looks like.
We know SEO.
You know the business.
It works much better when we combine the two.
How much budget do you need for an SEO agency?
This varies massively.
A local business competing in a relatively small market needs a very different level of resource from an ecommerce business targeting competitive searches nationally.
At Surge, our SEO services currently start from £500 + VAT per month, with many clients investing more depending on the amount of work required. We’ve covered the numbers in more detail in our guide to how much SEO services cost in the UK.
But the bigger question is whether that investment makes commercial sense.
If an average new customer is worth £20,000 to your business, generating a handful of additional customers through organic search could justify a substantial SEO budget.
If your average sale is £15, the maths looks very different.
We’d rather understand those numbers before deciding what level of SEO actually makes sense.
What should an SEO company actually take off your plate?
Quite a lot.
You shouldn’t be paying an SEO company and then still having to work out what needs doing every month.
They should be bringing the thinking as well as doing the work.
That means understanding your business, identifying the opportunities, deciding what deserves attention first and explaining why.
The actual work might involve technical fixes, keyword research, content, service-page optimisation, competitor analysis, reporting or improving how pages convert.
But you shouldn’t need to manage that checklist yourself.
If you want a deeper look at what that relationship should involve, we’ve covered it in What Is an SEO Agency?
How do you know if an SEO agency is actually good?
Ignore the biggest promises for a minute.
Ask how they think.
Do they ask about your business before talking about keywords?
Can they explain what they’d prioritise and why?
Will they tell you when something isn’t working?
Can they show you examples of businesses they’ve helped?
Do they talk about enquiries and revenue as well as rankings and traffic?
And can they explain SEO without making you feel like you need a dictionary?
At Surge, our approach starts with understanding what the business is actually trying to achieve, then prioritising the SEO work most likely to help get there. We don’t sell SEO as the same monthly checklist for every client.
That’s the sort of thing we’d look for whichever agency you choose.
So, do you need an SEO company?
Here’s the easiest way to think about it.
You probably don't need an SEO company if you’ve got the time, knowledge and resource internally to consistently improve your website and you’re happy with the results you’re getting.
You probably should consider one if SEO is becoming important to the business but nobody has the time or specialist knowledge to give it the attention it needs.
And you probably definitely need some help if organic search matters to your business, performance is going backwards and nobody can tell you why.
Hiring an SEO agency shouldn’t be about handing over your website and hoping for the best.
It should give you clarity.
What are we trying to achieve?
What’s getting in the way?
What are we doing about it?
And is it working?
If you’re currently trying to decide whether outsourcing SEO makes sense, have a look through our SEO case studies and SEO services.
And if you’d rather just talk it through, get in touch. Tell us where you are, what you’re trying to achieve and what you’ve already tried.
If we think SEO can help, we’ll explain how.
If we don’t think it’s the right move, we’ll tell you that too.